A Practical + Inspiring Guide for Today’s Leaders

Choosing an executive coach is one of the most high-leverage decisions a leader can make. The right coach can elevate your leadership, sharpen your strategic clarity, strengthen your emotional intelligence, and unlock performance across your team. But the wrong fit? It can waste money, time, and momentum.

In a world where leadership expectations are rapidly evolving, leaders need more than a mentor—they need a trusted thinking partner who challenges, inspires, and accelerates their growth.

According to Forbes leadership contributors, high-performing executives increasingly turn to CEO coaches to build adaptability, decision-making discipline, and people-first leadership skills. And Gallup’s leadership research has repeatedly shown that leaders who invest in self-awareness, strengths development, and emotional intelligence drive significantly higher engagement and performance within their organizations.

So… how do you know if an executive coach is the right fit for you?

Below is a clear, research-backed, inspirational guide to help you make a confident choice.

1. They Start With You — Not Their Framework

Great coaches don’t start with a pre-packaged program.
They start with your goals, your strengths, your challenges, and your context.

A strong fit is a coach who asks questions like:

• “What outcomes matter most right now?”
• “What decisions feel heavy or unclear?”
• “What’s the impact you want to create as a leader?”
  
  

Gallup’s research highlights that leaders who lean into their unique strengths outperform those who don’t. The right coach will help you discover, refine, and leverage your strengths, not fit you into a generic leadership box.

If the conversation feels personalised from the first interaction, you’re likely in the right place.

2. They Challenge You More Than They Comfort You

A coach isn’t there to agree with you. They’re there to grow you.

Forbes often notes that elite executives prefer coaches who are honest, direct, and unafraid to challenge assumptions. A strong coach will:

• Catch blind spots
• Interrupt unhelpful patterns
• Ask uncomfortable questions
• Push your thinking beyond autopilot
  

You should leave sessions feeling:

✔ stretched
✔ reflective
✔ empowered
✔ accountable

If you feel slightly “cracked open” after talking to them, that’s a strong sign.

3. Their Experience Aligns With the Stage You’re In

You don’t need a coach who has had your exact career—
but you do need someone who understands your landscape.

Ask about their experience coaching:

• Executives at your level
• Leaders in similar industries
• Teams experiencing similar challenges (rapid growth, restructuring, low engagement, cultural transformation, etc.)
  

Look for alignment with themes noted in Gallup’s leadership studies:
strengths development, engagement, communication, trust-building, and accountability systems.

A coach with relevant pattern-recognition can fast-track your growth.

4. Their Values Match Your Leadership Style

Coaching isn’t purely technical—
it’s a values and energy fit.

Reflect on questions like:

• Do they communicate in a way that resonates with you?
• Do they feel grounded, trustworthy, and credible?
• Do you feel safe to be honest with them?
• Do their leadership philosophies align with your own?
  

Leaders work best with coaches who share similar beliefs about people, performance, and growth. Forbes research widely emphasises the importance of psychological safety for effective executive development.

If the relationship feels natural and energising, it’s a great sign.

5. They Use Evidence-Based Methods

Strong coaches don’t rely on intuition alone.
They use proven, research-driven tools.

That might include:

• Strengths assessments (Gallup StrengthsFinder themes are widely used)
• 360° feedback
• Leadership capability frameworks
• Behavioural assessments
• Strategic decision-making tools
  

A good fit is a coach who can explain how they coach, why they coach that way, and what results you can expect.

If their approach is grounded in research and results, you’ll feel more confident investing in the process.

6. You See Measurable Results Early

Coaching shouldn’t feel vague.

You should notice changes like:

• Clearer thinking
• Improved communication
• Better decision-making
• More confidence
• Less reactivity
• Increased focus
• A shift in how your team responds to you
  

Executive coaching—according to many thought leaders featured in Forbes—produces ROI in the form of better execution, productivity, and leadership behaviour shifts.

If within the first few weeks you feel clarity increasing, momentum growing, or stress decreasing, you’re in the right coaching relationship.

7. You Trust Them

This is the single biggest indicator.

Coaching only works when you feel safe enough to:

• Say what you’re really thinking
• Explore your doubts
• Admit mistakes
• Challenge your own narratives
  

Trust creates the space for transformation.

If you feel you can speak freely—without judgment—you’ve found your coach.

Final Thought: Coaching Is a Partnership, Not a Purchase

Your executive coach should feel like a strategic ally—
someone who sees your potential, challenges your limitations, and supports your evolution as a leader.

If a coach helps you think clearer, act braver, and lead with more purpose…
then yes—you’ve found the right fit.

‍